Tea and Simpering: A Cheerleader's Guide to Growing Up (Condensed) "Vanities" at TheatreWorks *1/2 (out of *****) Mark S.P. Turvin (w) 965-1021 (h) 894-5443 I can be reached for comment via e-mail at: mspt@asu.edu If it's been said once, it's been said a million times: with mediocre material, a production is doomed from the start. "Vanities," a little nothing of a show concerning a ten year period for three popular friends as they (supposedly) grow up and grow apart, is a favorite of community and dinner theatres for many reasons, not the least of which is that it is a quaint, facadal, nostalgic look at the '60s and '70s. For every weighty feminist issue that's gingerly ventured near, there are plenty of cute references to the staples of cheerleading, sorority life, and other important things revolving around these three Texas girls. This much can be said for the show: it's cutesy, it's a button- pusher for people who yearn for easier times, and it's about as dramatically interesting as an evening in a darkened theatre. With this already against it, the production of this simplistic show is then hampered by unbalanced acting and uninspired direction. The three women in the cast, Valley veterans Cathy Dresbach as the happy homemaker-wannabe Joanne and Robyn Allen as the determined, A-type personality Kathy, and recent transplant Martha Magee as the independent, strong-willed Mary, play their respective roles at turns unconvincingly and even a bit smugly. Ms. Magee's performance is the best of the three, possibly owing to the fact that her role had some kind of discernible character movement from beginning to end, and that she also was the only one who looked even close to her character's age. Ms. Dresbach's character, already a walking stereotype, is given a general gloss of a presentation by the actress. While her accent was dead-on, at times her performance is as flat as a Texas prairie. She does well when the dialogue is zippy and funny, but when she plays dramatic, she is unable to flesh out anything truly believable. The most puzzling of the performances comes from Ms. Allen, who plays the first two acts of three tongue-in-cheek. There is a sense, from her delivery, that she knows how ludicrous some of her lines are, and is giving them an inappropriate ironic reading. In the third act, her presentation becomes mysteriously dark and dramatic, much, much more so than the situation calls for. Her characterization is so somber, in fact, that it throws off the balance in what winds up being the weakest of the tea parties. Dina Kay's direction and staging is nothing remarkable, either good or bad. Where the show does well is in the versatile set design by Gregory Jaye, lighting by David Wo and on-target costuming by Margret Emerson. The unit set changes fluidly from high-school auditorium to sorority room to well-appointed garden apartment with the ever-present vanities behind. The period costumes work perfectly, from cheerleader pom-poms to Mary's pop-art mini-dress. This final offering of TheatreWork's tenth summer season is undoubtedly the weakest of the presentations, but there will be those who lived through this era (1963 through 1974) who will enjoy the references and attitudes portrayed. If a trip down memory lane is what you're after, though, I'd recommend renting "American Graffiti" or "Easy Rider" instead. Production Details: "Vanities" by Jack Heifner TheatreWorks, Peoria 815-1791 August 23rd through September 8th, 1996 $9-$12 -30-