Archived Reviews of the 2004/2005 Season's Productions


A Letter from Summer Camp
Artists' Theatre Project's Vampire Lesbians of Sodom and Sleeping Beauty or; Coma 7/8/05 - 7/21/05

Charity by Committee
Desert Stages Theatre's Sweet Charity 6/24/05 - 7/31/05

A Mid-summer's Midsummer
The Shakespeare Theatre's A Midsummer Night's Dream 7/1/05 - 7/23/05

James Borgmann, Egeus in The Shakespere Theatre's current production of A Midsummer Night's Dream, disagrees with my way of commenting on his performance, and my response

A member of the theatre community who wishes to remain annonymous responds to James Borgmann's challenge with a simple Google search that resulted in this link to a review by a critic specifically citing a "memorable Egeus" in paragraphs 6 and 7

A Tasty Chocolate Cream Confection
Shakespeare Sedona's Arms and the Man 7/2/05 - 7/23/05

Not Worth Peeking in a Key Hole For
Fountain Hills Community Theatre's What the Butler Saw 6/17/05 - 7/10/05

Local actor/dialect coach Diane Senffner comments on the circumstances leading to my review of FHCT's What the Butler Saw , and my reply

Opposite Ends of the Season, Opposite Ends of the Valley, Opposite Ends of the Spectrum
Tempe Little Theatre's Company 6/10/05 - 6/26/05

Local actor Brad Rupp agrees with me on my review of TLT's Company

Maria Get Your Gun
Broadway Palm West Dinner Theatre's The Sound of Music 6/9/05 - 7/30/05

Michael Shell offers a formal apology for his negative personal comments concerning my review of an actress in Broadway Palm West's production of The Sound of Music

E2! True Monarchy Stories
Nearly Naked Theatre's E2: A Heretical Adaptation of Christopher Marlowe's Edward the Second 6/3/05 - 6/25/05

He's Got a Lot of Living to Do
iTheatre Collaborative's Gallows Humor 6/3/05 - 6/19/05

Performing Against the Odds
Desert Rose Theatre's The Lark 5/18/05 - 5/21/05

“This parting must be / endured, Sappho. I go unwillingly.”
Stray Cat Theatre's Stop Kiss 5/13/05 - 5/28/05

Local actor/director Kimberlee Hart agrees with my review of SCT's Stop Kiss

The Weird Sisters Have a Deadline for Fascist Macbeth
Arizona Theatre Company's Macbeth 5/5/05 - 5/22/05

Overly Merry Maids
iTheatre Collaborative's The Maids 4/29/05 - 5/15/05

Guest Review by Jackson Fisher
Hale Centre Theatre's The Curious Savage 4/7/05 - 5/14/05

The Curious Savage: A quick note from local actor
Bill Graham - 5/1/05

The Curious Savage: A longer critique from a local stage manager and properties person (and, in the spirit of full disclosure, my wife's best friend)
Eva Richards - 4/21/05

The Curious Savage: A short comment from a local actress (with whom I've worked in the past)
Barbara McBain - 4/17/05

Like Cotton Candy, but Lacking the Flavor
M&I Bank Broadway in Arizona ASU Gammage Auditorium's Thoroughly Modern Millie 5/3/05 - 5/8/05

The Oy of the Beholder
Actors Theatre's Sight Unseen 4/22/05 - 5/8/05

You can lead blue-hairs to culture, but you can't make them think.
Phoenix Theatre's And They Dance Real Slow in Jackson 4/13/05 - 5/1/05

Pardon me, but I think you forgot abortion...
Is What It Is Theatre's 102 4/15/05 - 5/1/05

A "Band of Brothers" in Cargo Pants
Southwest Shakespeare Company's Henry V 4/7/05 - 4/16/05

Critical Condition
Tempe Little Theatre's Critic's Choice 3/25/05 - 4/10/05

Acting Out
Desert Foothills Community Theatre's Moon Over Buffalo 3/17/05 - 4/3/05

When Black and White Obscures Color
Arizona Theatre Company's Permanent Collection 3/24/05 - 4/10/05

Local actor Bill Graham agrees with my review of ATC's production of Permanent Collection

Soft Shue
Fountain Hills Community Theatre's The Nerd 3/18/05 - 4/3/05

Some Win, Some Place in this Show
Broadway Palm West Dinner Theatre's Guys and Dolls 2/17/05 - 4/4/05

Observing the Consequences of the Zipless Fuck
Nearly Naked Theatre's Sexual Perversity in Chicago 3/18/05 - 3/26/05

They Prohibited the Wrong Thing in the 20s
Nearly Naked Theatre's Les Liaisons Dangereuses 3/11/05 - 3/26/05

The Darkness of Sight
iTheatre Collaborative's Molly Sweeney 3/11/05 - 3/27/05

A Flash of the Old Days
Scottsdale Community Players' The Foreigner 3/4/05 - 3/20/05

Bigger than Necessary, but Still Great
Actors Theatre's The Last Five Years 3/5/05 - 3/20/05

The Night Larry Kramer Kicked Me
Stray Cat Theatre's The Normal Heart 2/17/05 - 3/12/05

A Well-Meaning Shipwreck
Desert Stages Theatre's Gilligan's Island: The Musical

Divvying Up the Blame
Arizona Jewish Theatre Company's The Price 2/12/05 - 2/27/05

Disney Does Broadway Right
ASU Gammage Auditorium M&I Bank's Valley Broadway Series' The Lion King 1/20/05 - 3/6/05

Feydeau's Don't
Arizona Theatre Company's For Better or Worse Tucson 1/15/05 - 2/5/05 and Phoenix 2/10/05 - 2/27/05

From a Crypt, New Life
Desert Rose Theatre's Romeo and Juliet 2/11/05 - 2/19/05

Great Fun at the Kit Kat Kloset
Fountain Hills Community Theatre's Cabaret 1/21/05 - 2/13/05

How the Other Half Starves
Actors Theatre's Nickle and Dimed 1/22/05 - 2/6/05

Historical Inevitability
iTheatre Collaborative's Topdog/Underdog 1/28/05 - 2/12/05

A Lifeless Lear
Southwest Shakespeare's King Lear 1/13/05 - 1/29/05

The Best Whorehouse I've Been To
Desert Foothills Theatre's The Best Little Whorehouse in Texas 1/13/05 - 1/30/05

A Singular Sensation
Phoenix Theatre's A Chorus Line 1/12/05 - 2/6/05

Simple Times, Simpler Solutions
Hale Centre Theatre's Barefoot in the Park 12/30/04 - 2/12/05

Hot Mama
Broadway Palm West Dinner Theatre's Gypsy 12/30/04 - 2/12/04

The Pride of Her Majesty's Pirates
Arizona Theatre Company's The Pirates of Penzance 12/30/04 - 1/23/05

The Sopranos do Karaoke Shakespeare
The Shakespeare Theatre's Romeo and Juliet 12/31/04 - 1/15/05

Jest Barely
Arizona Jewish Theatre Company's Beau Jest and Jest a Second! (reviewed in tandem 12/19/04) 12/18/04 - 1/9/05

Jere Van Patten, a member of the cast of Hale Center Theatre's A Christmas Carol asks why I'm not reviewing their production, and my response

Enough for the Kids and the Connoisseurs
Ballet Arizona's The Nutcracker Suite 12/3/04 - 12/26/04

Andrew Ranshaw, the Prince in Ballet Arizona's The Nutcracker Suite thanks me for my review

A Little Easter for Christmas
ASU Gammage Auditorium M&I Bank's Broadway in Arizona Series' Jesus Christ Superstar 12/7/04 - 12/12/04

Still much to do with this Much Ado
Actors Renaissance Theatre's Much Ado About Nothing 12/3/04 - 12/18/04

Sometimes a Cigar is Just a Good Smoke
Arizona Theatre Company's Anna in the Tropics 11/18/04 - 12/5/04

Fear and Loathing in La La Land
Nearly Naked Theatre's Hurlyburly 11/12/04 - 12/4/04

A Sad So Long to Theater Works
Theater Works' Company 11/5/04 - 11/21/04

Local actor Jesse Berger explains why he's upset about my leaving Theater Works' Company at intermission, and my reply

Actress Toni Hull, a member of the cast of Theater Works' Company whom I did not review as I left at intermission, attacks me for my review of that production, and my response

Actress/Director Kimberlee Hart, who recently directed a show at Theater Works, takes issue with my comments about the company and its administration, and my response

Jack Lytle, the C.E.O. of Theater Works, suggests that I'm lacking understanding, and my response

Peter J. Hill, the Artistic Director of Fountain Hills Community Theatre and Copperstate Dinner Theatre, comments on my call last season to support Theater Works versus my recent removal of such support, and my response

Local actress of stage and screen Mandy Nichols, who DID NOT see any of the contested productions about which I've recently received email, thanks me for my tact. Wow.

The Power of the Ensemble
arizona women's theatre company's Necessary Targets 11/5/04 - 11/28/04

Drowning in Mediocrity
ASU Gammage Auditorium M&I Bank's Valley Broadway Series The Graduate 11/9/04 - 11/14/04

Denting Yonkers' Heart of Steel
Arizona Jewish Theatre Company's Lost in Yonkers 11/6/04 - 11/21/04

Playwriting, Producing, and Pasta Fagioli
Desert Foothill's Theatre's Breaking Legs 11/5/04 - 11/21/04

The Nuts Don't Fall Far From the Sycamores
Phoenix Theatre's You Can't Take it With You 11/3/04 - 11/21/04

Seinfeld meets Ionesco
Stray Cat Theatre's [sic] 10/29/04 - 11/20/04

The Loonies Carry the Night
Hale Centre Theatre's Arsenic and Old Lace 10/14/04 - 11/27/04

Florence and Oscar go to The Odd Couples
Copperstate Dinner Theatre's The Odd Couple and The Odd Couple (Female Version) A He-Said/She Said Review of Both Versions with a Guest Review by the Arizona Production Association's Julie Lee 9/24/04 - 11/21/04

Must See Simon!?! Pela Forgive Me.
Tempe Little Theatre's Chapter Two 10/29/04 - 11/7/04

Still Crazy After All These Years
Fountain Hills Community Theatre's One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest 10/21/04 - 11/7/04

Someone Else's Bordertown
Actors Theatre's Bordertown 10/23/04 - 11/7/04

Theatre of the Awkward
THEATRESCAPE'S The Elephant Man 10/7/04 - 11/7/04

Viola in the Tropics
Southwest Shakespeare Theatre's Twelfth Night 10/7/04 - 10/16/04

Hearts of Texas
Arizona Theatre Company's The Immigrant 10/7/04 - 10/24/04

She's Great, I Hear
Theater League's Tea at Five 10/5/04 - 10/10/04

The "Eat" is on in Saigon
Broadway Palm West Dinner Theatre's Miss Saigon 9/30/04 - 11/13/04

A vitriolic letter from actor Patrick O'Herron ripping me for my lack of preparation and education in reviewing Miss Saigon by Broadway Palm West Dinner Theatre, my equally nasty response, and his subsequent apology to all involved

Local Actor Peter Good responds to Patrick O'Herron's letter

Local Actress and frequent performer for Broadway Palm West Nicole Savitt responds to Patrick O'Herron's letter

Local Actor Ben Medina, a member of the Miss Saigon cast, responds to Patrick O'Herron's letter

Ring My Belle
Tempe Little Theatre's Steel Magnolias 9/24/04 - 10/10/04

The Madness of Wes Martin
The Shakespeare Theatre's Marat/Sade 9/24/04 - 10/9/04

Unbalanced Art
Algonquin Theatre Company's Art 9/17/04 - 10/3/04

Not-So Down and Out in Berlin
Phoenix Theatre's Cabaret 9/8/04 - 10/3/04

Averting a Disaster
Scottsdale Community Player's Titanic 9/10/04 - 9/26/04

Putting a Handsome Face on an Ugly Script
Fountain Hills Community Theatre's Jekyll and Hyde 9/3/04 - 9/26/04

Heaven Can Wait; The Audience, However, Has No Choice
Hale Centre Theatre's Heaven Can Wait 8/13/04 - 9/25/04

Grrls Night Out
Desert Stages Theatre's A...My Name is Alice 8/27/04 - 9/19/04

Who's Afraid of Virginia Sacrifice?
Nearly Naked Theatre's The Rocky Horror Show 8/27/04 - 9/19/04

Choice Cuts of Meat (and a Great Meal)
Copperstate Dinner Theatre's Ashes to Ashes 7/23/04 - 9/12/04

"On an occasion of this kind, it becomes more than a moral duty to speak one's mind, it becomes a pleasure."
Actors Renaissance Theatre's The Importance of Being Earnest 8/27/04 - 9/5/04

Cut Loose Footloose
Theater Works' Footloose 8/13/04 - 9/5/04

A Letter from Kimberlee Hart, Director of Theater Works' Footloose, responding to my review

The Simultaneous Fall and Rise of Love
Ovation Theatre Troupe's The Last Five Years 8/20/04 - 9/5/04

Would You Be My (Fuck)Buddy?
Stray Cat Theatre's Poona the Fuckdog...and Other Plays for Children 8/13/04 - 9/5/04

I Love It, It's Perfect, Don't Change (Much)
Desert Stages Actor's Café's I Love You, You're Perfect, Now Change 7/14/04 - Now Closed

A Letter from Copperstate Dinner Theatre's Artistic Director Peter J. Hill impuning my impartiality in choosing to review Stray Cat Theatre's Poona the Fuckdog, and my response

A Letter from Actor Steve Scally, a member of the cast of Poona the Fuckdog, responding to Peter J. Hil

lA Letter from Copperstate Dinner Theatre's Artistic Director Peter J. Hill responding to Steve Scally's letter

A Letter from valley actress Andi Watson weighing in on my impartiality, and my response

Shakespeare in Limbo
THEATRESCAPE's Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead 8/5/04 - 8/29/04

Invasion of the Definitely Ready for Prime Time Players
Mesa Community College Music Department's Fundraiser Little Shop of Horrors 7/30/04 - 8/8/04

Shameless Pirates
Hale Centre Theatre's The Pirates of Penzance 6/25/04 - 8/7/04

Electricity Comes to River City
Broadway Palm West Dinner Theatre's The Music Man 6/18/04 - 8/7/04

Earnest, Energetic, if Not Exactly Good Performances
Desert Stage's The Best Little Whorehouse in Texas 7/9/04 - 7/25/04

Sticks and Stones may Break Your Bones, but Words will Surely Kill You
The Shakespeare Theatre's Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf? 7/2/04 - 7/17/04

Athena Reiss' number one fan sends a letter

Former Phoenix actor Michael Sherwin thanks me for the role goldfishpublishers.com played in helping him land a role in a play in his new home in Chicago, and my response

Former Phoenix actor Ben Brittain drops a line to let everyone in the community know how things are going in his new home

A Letter from actress Karen Binder taking issue with my inclusion of last season's Jesus Christ Superstar by Scottsdale Community Players on my Fishy List, and my response

A Letter from The Shakespeare Theatre's Executive Producer Wes Martin to Bobb Cooper explaining his planned absence from this year's ariZoni Award Presentation

A Letter from Copperstate Dinner Theatre's Artistic Director Peter J. Hill commenting on my review of Desert Stages' I Love You, You're Perfect, Now Change, and my response

A Letter from Susan Banqueparch pointedly commenting on her perception of my conflicts in giving out awards and reviewing, and my response

A Letter from Director Diane Rodriguez of L.A.'s Latino Theatre Initiative at the Mark Taper Forum commenting on my past reviews of shows she'd directed in Phoenix, and my response

A Letter asking about my policy of not revewing colleges in relation to the Goldy Awards, and my response


Questions? Comments? I truly encourage reciprication and dialogue. Drop me a cybernote at:
mspt@goldfishpublishers.com