| Category | Winner | Show | Theatre |
| Non-Contracted Theatre | |||
| Choreography | Robbie Harper | How To Succeed in Business W/O Really Trying | MCC Act One Musical Productions |
| Choreography | Roger Prenger | West Side Story | Tempe Little Theatre |
| Costume Design | Noel Irick | Noises Off | Copperstate Dinner Theatre |
| Costume Design | Diane Welle | Lend Me A Tenor | Desert Foothills Community Theater |
| Costume Design | Emily Bonanni | The Miracle Worker | Theatre Eclectic |
| Director - Musical | Peter J. Hill | Man of La Mancha | Copperstate Dinner Theatre |
| Director - Musical | Noel Irick | Man of La Mancha | Copperstate Dinner Theatre |
| Director - Musical | Robbie Harper | How To Succeed in Business W/O Really Trying | MCC Act One Musical Productions |
| Director - Play | Peter J. Hill | Noises Off | Copperstate Dinner Theatre |
| Director - Play | Peter J. Hill | The Woman In Black | Fountain Hills Community Theatre |
| Director - Play | Damon Dering | Shakespeare's R&J | Nearly Naked Theatre |
| Director - Play | Gary Stephens | Noises Off | Theatre Outback |
| Guest Actor - Play | Patti Suarez | The House of Yes | Nearly Naked Theatre |
| Hair and Make-up Design | Noel Irick | Man of La Mancha | Copperstate Dinner Theatre |
| Hair and Make-up Design | Noel Irick | Noises Off | Copperstate Dinner Theatre |
| Lighting Design | Peter J. Hill | The Woman In Black | Fountain Hills Community Theatre |
| Lighting Design | Mike Eddy | How To Succeed in Business W/O Really Trying | MCC Act One Musical Productions |
| Musical Direction | Alan Ruch | How To Succeed in Business W/O Really Trying | MCC Act One Musical Productions |
| Musical Direction | Cathy Hauan | I Love You, You're Perfect, Now Change | MCC Act One Musical Productions |
| Overall Production - Musical | How To Succeed in Business W/O Really Trying | MCC Act One Musical Productions | |
| Overall Production - Musical | I Love You, You're Perfect, Now Change | MCC Act One Musical Productions | |
| Overall Production - Original Musical | Unsung | Fountain Hills Community Theatre | |
| Overall Production - Original Play | 14 | Teatro Bravo | |
| Overall Production - Play | Noises Off | Copperstate Dinner Theatre | |
| Overall Production - Play | The Woman In Black | Fountain Hills Community Theatre | |
| Principal Actor - Musical | Roy Hunt | Man of La Mancha | Copperstate Dinner Theatre |
| Principal Actor - Musical | Phillip Fazio | How To Succeed in Business W/O Really Trying | MCC Act One Musical Productions |
| Principal Actor - Musical | Terry Gadaire | A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum | Phoenix Theatre |
| Principal Actor - Play | Charles Sohn | The Woman In Black | Fountain Hills Community Theatre |
| Principal Actor - Play | Michael Peck | Love Waits | On The Spot Theater |
| Principal Actress - Musical | Ange Mitchell | West Side Story | Tempe Little Theatre |
| Principal Actress - Musical | Brandi Bigley | West Side Story | Tempe Little Theatre |
| Principal Actress - Play | Noel Irick | Noises Off | Copperstate Dinner Theatre |
| Principal Actress - Play | Kerry McCue | Twelfth Night, Or What You Will | The Shakespeare Theatre |
| Scenic Design | Peter J. Hill | Man of La Mancha | Copperstate Dinner Theatre |
| Scenic Design | Gregory Jaye | Noises Off | Copperstate Dinner Theatre |
| Sound Design | Jesse Berger | The Woman In Black | Fountain Hills Community Theatre |
| Sound Design | Evan Neill | Julius Caesar | The Shakespeare Theatre |
| Supporting Actor - Musical | Bruce Halperin | Guys & Dolls | MCC Act One Musical Productions |
| Supporting Actor - Musical | Ben Giroux | How To Succeed in Business W/O Really Trying | MCC Act One Musical Productions |
| Supporting Actor - Musical | David Chorley | How To Succeed in Business W/O Really Trying | MCC Act One Musical Productions |
| Supporting Actor - Play | Jesse Berger | Noises Off | Copperstate Dinner Theatre |
| Supporting Actor - Play | Franc Gaxiola | Waiting For Godot | Is What It Is Theatre |
| Supporting Actress - Musical | Patti Jones | Grease | MCC Act One Musical Productions |
| Supporting Actress - Musical | Tiffany Broshar | How To Succeed in Business W/O Really Trying | MCC Act One Musical Productions |
| Supporting Actress - Play | Gina Tleel | Lend Me A Tenor | Desert Foothills Community Theater |
| Supporting Actress - Play | Barbara Acker | 14 | Teatro Bravo |
| Supporting Actress - Play | Isabel Sans | Romeo y Julieta | Tetro Bravo |
| Contracted Theatre | |||
| Choreography | Millie Garvey | West Side Story | Broadway Palm Dinner Theatre |
| Choreography | Linda Love-Simmons | Swing! | Phoenix Theatre |
| Choreography | Robert Harper | Swing! | Phoenix Theatre |
| Costume Design | Cari Smith | Rapunzel | Cookie Company |
| Costume Design | Timothy Slope | A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum | Phoenix Theatre |
| Director - Musical | Marc Robin | Cats | Broadway Palm Dinner Theatre |
| Director - Musical | Michael Barnard | A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum | Phoenix Theatre |
| Director - Musical | Michael Barnard | Chicago | Phoenix Theatre |
| Director - Play | David Saar | Sideways Stories From Wayside School | Childsplay |
| Director - Play | Jared Sakren | Richard III | Southwest Shakespeare Company |
| Hair and Make-up Design | Dawn Rivard | Cats | Broadway Palm Dinner Theatre |
| Hair and Make-up Design | Manuella Needhammer | Rapunzel | Cookie Company |
| Hair and Make-up Design | Manuella Needhammer | A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum | Phoenix Theatre |
| Lighting Design | Paul A. Black | Frame 312 | Actor's Theatre |
| Lighting Design | Russell Thompson | West Side Story | Broadway Palm Dinner Theatre |
| Musical Direction | JR McAlexander | Cats | Broadway Palm Dinner Theatre |
| Musical Direction | JR McAlexander | West Side Story | Broadway Palm Dinner Theatre |
| Musical Direction | Ron Colvard | Chicago | Phoenix Theatre |
| Overall Production - Musical | Cats | Broadway Palm Dinner Theatre | |
| Overall Production - Musical | Chicago | Phoenix Theatre | |
| Overall Production - Original Musical | Taking The Wrath out of Math | Cookie Company | |
| Overall Production - Original Play | The Imaginators | Childsplay | |
| Overall Production - Play | Cat on a Hot Tin Roof | Actor's Theatre | |
| Overall Production - Play | Morning's At Seven | Phoenix Theatre | |
| Overall Production - Play | Richard III | Southwest Shakespeare Company | |
| Principal Actor - Musical | John Gentry | A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum | Phoenix Theatre |
| Principal Actor - Musical | Robert Harper | A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum | Phoenix Theatre |
| Principal Actor - Play | Benjamin Stewart | Cat on a Hot Tin Roof | Actor's Theatre |
| Principal Actor - Play | James Kiberd | The Taming of the Shrew | Southwest Shakespeare Company |
| Principal Actress - Musical | Tracy Lore | Chicago | Phoenix Theatre |
| Principal Actress - Musical | Natalie Ellis | Chicago | Phoenix Theatre |
| Principal Actress - Play | Natalie Messersmith | Cat on a Hot Tin Roof | Actor's Theatre |
| Principal Actress - Play | Peggy Lord | Morning's At Seven | Phoenix Theatre |
| Scenic Design | Christine Peters | West Side Story | Broadway Palm Dinner Theatre |
| Scenic Design | TJ Weltzien | Rapunzel | Cookie Company |
| Scenic Design | Gregory Jaye | Morning's At Seven | Phoenix Theatre |
| Scenic Design | Bill Symington | Private Lives | Phoenix Theatre |
| Sound Design | Adam Larsen | Sideways Stories From Wayside School | Childsplay |
| Sound Design | Dave Temby | Chicago | Phoenix Theatre |
| Supporting Actor - Musical | Denny McNamara | Honk! | Broadway Palm Dinner Theatre |
| Supporting Actor - Musical | Andrew Ragone | A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum | Phoenix Theatre |
| Supporting Actor - Musical | Jim Roehr | Chicago | Phoenix Theatre |
| Supporting Actor - Musical | George Pollard | A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum | Phoenix Theatre |
| Supporting Actor - Play | Jon Gentry | Sideways Stories From Wayside School | Childsplay |
| Supporting Actor - Play | Chris Vaglio | Morning's At Seven | Phoenix Theatre |
| Supporting Actress - Musical | Danielle Plisz | West Side Story | Broadway Palm Dinner Theatre |
| Supporting Actress - Musical | Terey Summers | Chicago | Phoenix Theatre |
| Supporting Actress - Play | Katie McFadzen | The Big Friendly Giant | Childsplay |
| Supporting Actress - Play | Robyn Allen | Morning's At Seven | Phoenix Theatre |
| Childrern's Theatre | |||
| Choreography | Jennifer Duxbury | Princess Furball | East Valley Children's Theatre |
| Choreography | Laurie Trygg | Annie Get Your Gun | Greasepaint Scottsdale Youththeatre |
| Choreography | Kelli James | You're A Good Man Charlie Brown | Valley Youth Theatre |
| Costume Design | Barbara Jakucki | Princess Furball | East Valley Children's Theatre |
| Costume Design | Karol Cooper | Titanic | Valley Youth Theatre |
| Costume Design | Shon LeBlanc | Titanic | Valley Youth Theatre |
| Director - Musical | D. Scott Withers | Annie Get Your Gun | Greasepaint Scottsdale Youththeatre |
| Director - Musical | Bobb Cooper | Titanic | Valley Youth Theatre |
| Director - Play | Anne Schindler | Princess Furball | East Valley Children's Theatre |
| Director - Play | Matthew Proschold | Pinocchio | Valley Youth Theatre |
| Guest Actor - Musical | Bobb Cooper | Annie | Valley Youth Theatre |
| Guest Actor - Musical | Tyler Service | Titanic | Valley Youth Theatre |
| Hair and Make-up Design | Karol Cooper | Pinocchio | Valley Youth Theatre |
| Hair and Make-up Design | Karol Cooper | Titanic | Valley Youth Theatre |
| Hair and Make-up Design | Cindy Margo | Titanic | Valley Youth Theatre |
| Lighting Design | Jon Gentry | Once on This Island | Greasepaint Scottsdale Youththeatre |
| Lighting Design | Mike Eddy | Charlotte's Web | Valley Youth Theatre |
| Lighting Design | Mike Eddy | Pinocchio | Valley Youth Theatre |
| Lighting Design | Mike Eddy | The Hobbit | Valley Youth Theatre |
| Lighting Design | Mike Eddy | Titanic | Valley Youth Theatre |
| Musical Direction | Alan Plado | Annie Get Your Gun | Greasepaint Scottsdale Youththeatre |
| Musical Direction | Mary Loose | Once on This Island | Greasepaint Scottsdale Youththeatre |
| Musical Direction | Mark Fearey | Annie | Valley Youth Theatre |
| Musical Direction | Mark Fearey | Titanic | Valley Youth Theatre |
| Overall Production - Musical | Annie Get Your Gun | Greasepaint Scottsdale Youththeatre | |
| Overall Production - Musical | Annie | Valley Youth Theatre | |
| Overall Production - Musical | Titanic | Valley Youth Theatre | |
| Overall Production - Original Musical | Cinderella: 2003 | Fountain Hills Youth Theatre | |
| Overall Production - Original Play | Princess Furball | East Valley Children's Theatre | |
| Overall Production - Play | Heidi | East Valley Children's Theatre | |
| Overall Production - Play | Pinocchio | Valley Youth Theatre | |
| Principal Actor - Musical | Brennan Hillard | Cinderella: 2003 | Fountain Hills Youth Theatre |
| Principal Actor - Musical | Tyler Smalley | Annie Get Your Gun | Greasepaint Scottsdale Youththeatre |
| Principal Actor - Play | JJ Janikis | Braille: The Early Life of Louis Braille | Fountain Hills Youth Theatre |
| Principal Actor - Play | Chad Gilbert | Pinocchio | Valley Youth Theatre |
| Principal Actress - Musical | Katie Olsen | Annie Get Your Gun | Greasepaint Scottsdale Youththeatre |
| Principal Actress - Musical | Amanda Glenn | Once on This Island | Greasepaint Scottsdale Youththeatre |
| Principal Actress - Play | Lindsay Wantlund | Heidi | East Valley Children's Theatre |
| Principal Actress - Play | Katie Chapman | Princess Furball | East Valley Children's Theatre |
| Scenic Design | Dr. Geof Eroe | Charlotte's Web | Valley Youth Theatre |
| Scenic Design | Dr. Geof Eroe | Pinocchio | Valley Youth Theatre |
| Scenic Design | Thom Buderwitz | Titanic | Valley Youth Theatre |
| Sound Design | Karen Rolston | Princess Furball | East Valley Children's Theatre |
| Sound Design | David Temby | Annie Get Your Gun | Greasepaint Scottsdale Youththeatre |
| Sound Design | Joe Moore | Pinocchio | Valley Youth Theatre |
| Supporting Actor - Musical | Luke Kanter | big, the musical | Greasepaint Scottsdale Youththeatre |
| Supporting Actor - Musical | Tyler Hornacek | Charlotte's Web | Valley Youth Theatre |
| Supporting Actor - Musical | Brandon Rivard | Titanic | Valley Youth Theatre |
| Supporting Actor - Play | Caleb Landrum | Heidi | East Valley Children's Theatre |
| Supporting Actor - Play | Or Skolnik | Pinocchio | Valley Youth Theatre |
| Supporting Actor - Play | Wolfram Ott II | The Hobbit | Valley Youth Theatre |
| Supporting Actress - Musical | Kyla Druckman | Cinderella: 2003 | Fountain Hills Youth Theatre |
| Supporting Actress - Musical | Emily Pelzer | Charlotte's Web | Valley Youth Theatre |
| Supporting Actress - Musical | Richelle Meiss | Titanic | Valley Youth Theatre |
| Supporting Actress - Play | Reshea Steisel | Princess Furball | East Valley Children's Theatre |
| Supporting Actress - Play | Megan Power | Princess Furball | East Valley Children's Theatre |
| Supporting Actress - Play | Jessica Fishell | An Irish Christmas Carol | Phoenix Center Youth Theater |
| Supporting Actress - Play | Nicole Nearhood | Pinocchio | Valley Youth Theatre |
| General Awards | |||
| Original Music Composition | Lew Bakey | Unsung | Fountain Hills Community Theatre |
| Original Music Composition | Miciah Dodge | Cinderella: 2003 | Fountain Hills Youth Theatre |
| Original Music Composition | Ross Collins | Cinderella: 2003 | Fountain Hills Youth Theatre |
| Original Music Composition | Michael Bradley | Twelfth Night, Or What You Will | The Shakespeare Theatre |
| Original Script - Musical | Lew Bakey | Unsung | Fountain Hills Community Theatre |
| Original Script - Musical | Ross Collins | Cinderella: 2003 | Fountain Hills Youth Theatre |
| Original Script - Play | Dwayne Hartford | The Imaginators | Childsplay |
| Original Script - Play | C. Lynn Johnson | Princess Furball | East Valley Children's Theatre |